Foley's Books | The Alsop Review  

Philip Whalen

Jack Foley

The recent death of at 78 of Philip Whalen (1923-2002) brings to an end the career of a brilliant, spiritually-striving poet whose work has been described as the product of  “a restless, self-consciously rhetorical sensibility.” In Donald M. Allen’s The New American Poetry, Whalen described his work in the following way:

This poetry is a picture or graph of a mind moving, which is a world body being here and now which is history...and you. Or think about the Wilson Cloud Chamber, not ideogram, not poetic beauty: bald-faced didacticism moving, as Dr. Johnson commands all poetry should, from the particular to the general. (Not that Johnson was right--nor that I am trying to inherit his mantle as a literary dictator but only the title Doctor, i.e. teacher, who is constantly studying.) I do not put down the academy but have assumed its function in my own person, and in the strictest sense of the word--academy--a walking grove of trees. But I cannot and will not solve any problems or answer any questions.

My life has been spent in the midst of heroic landscapes which never overwhelmed me and yet I live in a single room in the city--the room a lens focusing on a sheet of paper. Or the inside of your head. How do you like your world? (1959)

Because of his blindness, Whalen had not written poetry in recent years. I had this exchange with him:

Jack Foley to Philip Whalen: Have you been writing anything recently?

Philip Whalen: I can’t write, I’m blind!

Jack Foley: So was Homer!

Philip Whalen (after a short pause): Homer who?

We then went on to talk about Borges, Milton, and other blind poets.

Both Gary Snyder and Michael McClure were longtime friends of Whalen’s. Following is a statement by Gary Snyder and a poem by Michael McClure:

Gary Snyder
Date:
Sat, 29 Jun 2002 12:41:39 -0700
Subject: Zenshin enters Nirvana

Dear Friends,

Our great poet, Dharma Teacher, Zen Priest, bon vivant wit, and spiritual friend Philip Zenshin Whalen died 6:00 AM Wednesday the 25th of June [2002]. He was in Laguna Honda Nursing Home in San Francisco, and was attended by several old friends and students. Philip had been ailing for several years and the actual cause of his death remains unknown. I had just visited with him on June 20 and he was funny, lucid, but also speaking occasionally his imaginative fantasy journey life to other geographies, and we shared a pear-custard tart. Michael and Amy McClure were with him late in the evening before he died. He is being cremated on this Saturday the 29th [of June, 2002], attended by priests from San Francisco Zen Center. A memorial service will be held, probably at Green Gulch, sometime in mid-August. May Zenshin's great Bodhisattva Vows be realized.

Gone gone gone beyond gone beyond beyond Bodhi Svaha

Gary Chofu Snyder 29. VI. 02

 

FLOWER GARLAND FROTH           -- for Zenshin Ryufu, Philip Whalen

by Michael McClure

 

                  THROUGH THE SKANDHAS, THE BUNDLES

                       OF BRIGHTNESS AND HUNGERS,

                                                 arises

                                                          more FOAM

                    making foam with no origin

                but mutual reflection

 

                                            Taste   hunger   perception  thought

                                       

                                         NO

                                       JOKE

                                not even traps

 

                            gorgeous manacles

 

 

 

                                                           ((  physical form-bubbles

                                                               sensation-bubbles

                                                               perception-bubbles

                                                               conditioning-bubbles

                                                               consciousness-bubbles

                                              

 

                                               <<>>

                        MALLARME'S HUGE PASSIONS AND

                                                                  FRANCESCO CLEMENTE'S

                            tiny, skinny dark figures in the joy of their excrement

                                     and bright excitement, and Blake's fairies

                                               and caterpillars

                                     swimming in nada, right where we breathe

 

                                    The Circus of Celebration runs away

                                            with us  

                                                       (not us with the circus!)

                                                       pulling us out of the big top

                                                       like kernels from

                                                         a wrinkled shell

 

                                                       more foam

 

 

                                                  <<>>

 

 

                                FOAM POPPING BY THE SIDE OF THE RIVER

                                 rainbow bubbles burst, while reflecting all     
                                                  
                                        things

                                                   from a black smooth rock

                                                      made of bubbles

 

                                                         A white hand       

                                                             reaches

                                                         TO FILL A VASE

                                                       from the cool stream

 

                                                        Bronze vase clinks

                                                              on a stone

                                        

                                                        foam

                                                              More foam  

                                              <<>>

                                    FOAM WHERE A SKUNK DRINKS

                                             from the trickle    elegant black and white

                                        fur of foam

                                                       Sound of the water

 

                                                         foam   bubbles

 

                                                            FUR

                                                              OF

                                                               A

                                                       MOVING TRUCK

                                            in the wet forest    Paint chips

                                                           on mulch

                                               A huge presence and purpose

                                                  bursting into being

                                        with everything

 

                                                                  Solid nothing

                                                   <<>>  

                                          ... SOLID FOAM-BUBBLES BURSTING

                                      INTO OLD SHOES   NEW SHOES

                                              black with high tops

                                       bubbles of irridescent soil on

                                                                          the soles

 

                                          Smell of redwood and wet mulch

                                                   in countless realms of

                                                                          reflections

                                                        IN

 

                                                      JUST

                                                     one body

 

                                                       or none

                                                   trickling over the mirror

                                                          <<>>

 

                      HERE IS THE TRUE CONTENT OF EXPERIENCE

                    

                            THE UNTRUE CONTENT OF EXPERIENCE

 

                             silver raindrops falling on bubbles

                              Words spill from sleep                               

                                  Hungry ghosts behind trees

                                         push over dreams             NOT

                                                                 

                                                       TRUE

 

                                                Tiny black seeds

                                                rattle in an envelope

 

                                              BIG SCARLET FLOWERS

 

                                             Bubbles              

                                                                Foam

                                                          <<>>

 

                         A SWORD WITH EDGES OF FLAME

                                 slashes the walls     

 

                   BLACK ANTS CIRCLE A BUBBLE OF HONEY

                                          Zerbras, wildebeeste,

                                                            at the waterhole

 

                         Smell of red dust in the air

                                                                 is foam

                                       Uncoiling fiddle-neck ferns,

                                  astroturf,

                                              voices of wisdom

 

                         BLADE THROUGH A RAINBOW MEMBRANE

                                                            <<>>  

                                            EVERYTHING SMILING

                              with haloes and imaginary radiance

 

                                               ALL FOAM

                                                   

                                                    real

                                                as delusion

                              and the sunyatta physics of pond plants

                                    and hot air ducts

                                                 blowing into outburstings

                                   of snow banks

                                                        These caves

                               are inhabited by nothings constructed

                                        of bubbles                    

                                  I drive them around

                                                and eat them                                                  

 

                                                   <<>>  

                           FALCON SHAPES WOVEN IN GRAY SILK

 

                                Tension of plum buds

                                                               in night fog

                                 Stars a trillion years

                                                           from the mist

 

                                            BUBBLES

 

                                       all in one     

                                               ONE

                                           IN ALL

 

                                               Hidden in moss

                                   in the redwoods

                                                 near a Butterfinger wrapper

                                                    <<>>

 

                         THE SOUND OF THE DOWNPOUR ON WALLS

                                          is bubbles bursting

                                        into stuff of delusion,

                                fine as a new chip on an old tooth

 

                                              LIKE

                                     THE TECHNICOLOR MOVIE

                        of smells projected between raindrops

                                 on a screen of touches and tastes

 

                             The message of flannel is foam

                                        for the shoulders

                                            in the perfume

                                     while floorboards shine

 

                                              Perfectly clear 

                                                         <<>>

                               I RISE PROUD TO BE BEING

 

                                                  as

                                                   I

                                                  am

 

                                                and I

 

 

                                                  lie

 

                                                silent

 

                                                 NOT

                                               KNOWING

 

                                                  I

                                                Know

 

 

                                                  I

                                                know

                                       the long-gone delicacy

                                         and meat of apricots

                                       sun-heated on branches,

                                      and waves and caverns of fuel

                                           smashing the earth

                                          in the arising

                                                   and pouring

                                              of patterns

 

                                         I love those who fight this

 

                                                    I

 

 

                                                 HAND

                                                THEM

                                              the primate crown

                                                shimmering

                                          with hunger and automobiles

                                      and velvet and contracts and postage

                                         and duck weed and emeralds

                                                 and jazz

 

                                            THIS IS NOT MINE

                                            THIS WILL NOT BE MINE

                                            THIS IS NOT MINE

                                            THIS WILL NOT BE MINE

 

                                            This is not mind

                                            This will not be mind

 

                                             THIS IS NO BODY

                                             THIS WILL NOT BE BODY

 

                                                   Me </